If you want the fastest possible online purchase of a standard package, a startup insurer or a digital agency's program is built for that. If you want several carriers compared, higher limits, specialty markets (E&S, Lloyd's, Bermuda) or a careful read of AI exclusions, use an independent broker. Many companies start with the first and move to a broker as their risk and their investors' requirements grow.
The three models
| Model | How it works | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Independent and retail brokers | Don't carry risk; shop outside carriers for you and advocate at claim time. | Alton Risk; Vouch; The Baldwin Group's Innovation Practice (formerly Founder Shield); large national brokers |
| Digital agencies with their own programs | Licensed agencies that sell branded program policies written on a partner carrier's paper, with fast online binding. | Embroker (programs on Everspan and Everest paper) |
| Startup insurers (full-stack carriers) | The seller's own group writes and carries the insurance; usually the fastest online experience. | Corgi (risk retention group plus an admitted carrier launched in 2026) |
Head-to-head comparisons
- Alton Risk vs Corgi: Corgi is a startup insurer: its affiliated companies write the policies it sells, and most policies can be quoted and bound online in minutes.
- Alton Risk vs Vouch: Vouch and Alton Risk are both insurance brokers for growing tech companies: neither carries the risk, and both place policies with outside carriers.
- Alton Risk vs Embroker: Embroker is a licensed digital insurance agency that sells its own branded programs, written on outside carriers' paper (mainly Everspan), through a single online application.
- Alton Risk vs Founder Shield (Baldwin): Founder Shield, a New York startup broker founded in 2012, became part of The Baldwin Group in 2021 and in October 2026 was rebranded as Baldwin's Innovation Practice.
What AI companies should check
- AI exclusions. More Tech E&O and D&O forms now exclude or limit claims arising from AI output. Ask for the exact wording. See our AI liability guide.
- Affirmative AI coverage. Some markets now add AI coverage by endorsement or offer standalone AI liability; terms vary widely.
- Who carries the risk. A rated admitted carrier, a surplus lines insurer, Lloyd's and a risk retention group are regulated differently, and only some are backed by state guaranty funds.
- Investor and contract requirements. Term sheets, enterprise contracts and leases often specify limits and a minimum carrier rating.
Questions to ask any provider
- Who actually carries the risk, and what is that insurer's AM Best rating?
- Is the insurer admitted in my state, surplus lines, Lloyd's, or a risk retention group, and are policies covered by state guaranty funds?
- How many markets will you show me, and will you put my account in front of more than one carrier?
- How does the policy treat AI: is there an AI exclusion, and is there affirmative AI coverage?
- If I change brokers at renewal, can my coverage move with me?
- Who handles a claim, and who advocates for me if the carrier pushes back?